Saddest Warriors Book

[SilverRain]

The title pretty much says it all. Which Warriors book do you think was the saddest, or most tragic, or made you cry the most? And why?

For me, I'd have to say that Forest of Secrets was pretty sad, from Silverstream's death to Graystripe leaving Fireheart. Other than that, Moonrise was tragic for me, I loved Feathertail. And of course A Dangerous Path, with Bluestar's death. Hm, most of these are death related. And on that note, there haven't really been any sad Teapot books, considering that there haven't been any deaths really. If I'd have to pick a Teapot one, I'd say Dark River, just because I love Darkshipping and was so sad when it ended. D:


So, what do you all think?

[Jazzy <3]

Moonrise is certainly the saddest book for me. I burst into tears when Feathertail died because she was my favorite character at the time. It was so sad. =(

Twilight was also pretty sad because CinderPELT died. (I could care less if Cinderheart died...) At least I think that was the book she died in. It might have been Sunset... I dunno and I don't feel like walking across the room to my warriors books. xD

[SilverRain]

Yeah, it was right at the end of Twilight. Yes, that was tragic. I wish some people would die in Teapot.

[Jazzy <3]

Yes me too. (Like Cinderheart!) It should be a well loved character though. Warriors isn't the same without the deaths.

[Sandstar]

I found Twilight sad but in a completely different way. x______x

Forest of Secrets would be most tragic, then Moonrise.
I also thought A Dangerous Path was really sad, not just because of the deaths, but also because of the Bluestar/Mistyfoot/Stonefur thing. I felt really bad for Bluestar there... D=

[moss]

Sad in the pathetic sad way, Sandstar? xD

Uh, I don't think I can remember the books all that well to say which I think is the saddest. I mostly skimmed Moonrise and didn't know what was happening 90% of the time because I used it for a school project. Last time I read Forest of Secrets was a long time ago. Though I remember being a little bit sad in Twilight when Leafpool decided to run away.

[*~Ivory~*]

(In order of series)

Hmm, there's a tri-tie in the first arc, when Silverstream died and Graystripe had to leave, that was really sad.
When Bluestar died and Mistyfoot/Stonefur not knowing about Bluestar being their mother, I felt sad for Bluestar and them.
And The Darkest Hour, Whitestorm was my favorite character and he died, and Stonefur and the whole "Kill them [featherpaw and stormpaw]!" thing, that I felt so bad for him, and then he dies. -Now that I think of it, more cats died in the first two series than TPoT-

In Moonrise it was sad when Feathertail died, but not sad enough to make me cry though.
End of Twilight was so sad, when Cinderpelt died, I read it during school and started to tear up. And when Leafpool had to leave Crowfeather, that there was sad, because they're relationship just went downhill from there....

But I have to agree, there really aren't that sad of books in Teapot, unless you add relationships to that category, then maybe so.

[Rooster]

It's hard to remember all the way back to the older books, but I'm fairly sure that Forest of Secrets was the saddest book for me.
I remember being all teary-eyes when Graystripe left after Silverstream died. So depressing. D:

[[s]wift !]

I'd have to say The Darkest Hour. -sniffs- Tigey died....

But I thought how Firestar went through all this and that and this and that was frustrating and then Tigerstar died and he was sad and then Firestar killed Scourge...

Man, this just makes me realize how much more I hate Firestar.

[Larksong]

For me, it would be the Darkest Hour as well because Firestar lost his charm while Whitestorm and Stonefur died. Also, Tigerstar died one of the most brutal deaths I've ever read (ugh) and Scourge also died. I thought he was too awesome a villain to go like that. He should have been in more than just ONE book.

[Tinyfeather]

I cried when Cinderpelt died in Twilight. D= It was so sad. I was all "STUPID REINCARNATION" and stuff, too, so. xD

[blood]

The Darkest Hour. Whitestorm died!!! He is my favorite cat of all!!

[Sageheart]

No matter how many times I read the following books, I will always cry when the saddest scene happens.

Series 1
Forest of Secrets-Silverstream's death was one of the most heartwrenchingly, horribly sobering scenes in all the books. And I have to say that Brokentail's death was very depressing, the way he agonized before passing on.

Rising Storm-I didn't think I'd ever see the day Yellowfang joined the ranks of StarClan until I read that book. Death saving two(?) elders and a kit was noble, and certainly a fitting one for such a wonderful character. Why did Yellowfang have to die?

The Darkest Hour-I actually only cried twice in this book. When Gorsepaw and Whitestorm died. I was horrified at Stonefur's death, though.

The New Prophecy
Moonrise- was flat out sad. Feathertail was a lot like her mother, so why couldn't the Erins keep alive one pretty young cat for once? (save MAYBE Leafpool)

Twilight-EVERYTHING involving Cinderpelt in that book was sad. She was so brave about her death; no wonder she was reincarnated.

The Power of Three
Long Shadows-Ashfur. Poor, poor Ashfur. His mangled body was fould floating in a stream, murdered. I loved Ashfur so much, and then his life was ripped away. Sure: insane, yes; going to spill the beans, yes. Bad character? No. Depressing.

Sunrise-

SPOILER: Click to show

Honeyfern, Leafpool and Crowfeather, and Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw. Most teary, upsetting moments of any book in the series for me. ALL the series. And I don't think Hollyleaf is dead (too bad)